Tuesday, January 08, 2008

The 1-lakh car



The NY Times had a 2 page article about the 1-lakh Rupee "People's car" to be released soon by Tata Motors. It is being highlighted as a feat of engineering, being able to produce something at such a low price.

While there is some truth to that, I feel that not feats of engineering are beneficial. There are innumerable problems, which I am sure some of my Indian friends will concur with.

First is the congestion on the roads. There is close to no space on the roads for the vehicles currently on the streets. Add another million cars, I wouldn't want to be caught in the rush hour with those. Ramanand once talked about the lack of planning inherent with such things in India. He was talking about office space and how anyone can approve so many office buildings when the approach road into that area is clogged every rush hour. The 1 lakh car will be a similar debacle.

Second is parking. On my trips to Pune one of the biggest problems is parking and the second biggest problem is the increase in congestion from vehicles parked haphazardly on the sides of the roads. We hardly have any multi-storey parking structures.

Third issue is the rickshaw phenomenon. I personally think the rickshaw is one of the worst inventions ever. What's more is that rickshaw drivers will use kerosene instead of petrol and emit pollution enough for your eyes to catch. Could a similar effect be seen if we produce so many cheap cars? Gas prices are only going up. Even if you aren't as concerned by global warming, it does cause smog and increases rates of various respiratory disorders.

The only positive could be that assuming the People's car replaces most of the 2 and 3 wheelers, traffic may be more well-behaved.