On being a drop in the brain drain ocean
I just read
this excellent article on Sepia Mutiny about brain drain that got me thinking. I am a member of the brain drain generation. The vast majority of the people I studied with in engineering college (or high-school) are now working in America. I used to joke not too long ago that, I have a higher probability of bumping into a classmate from Pune in Silicon Valley than in Pune itself. I am not sure if that is a good thing or a bad thing, and I invite your perspective on the same. Another foregone conclusion among my contemporaries from Pune is that almost everyone ended up studying engineering (there are very few exceptions). With the plethora of engineering colleges in Pune, it is no surprise. I hate to be a walking talking cliche` in that regard.
The vast majority of my classmates who have continued to work in India, are working either directly or indirectly for large American multi-national firms. ( Intel, Texas Instruments, Motorola, IBM are some of the names for directly working for an American firm, and Infosys, Wipro, TCS for indirectly working for a multi-national firm.) I also work for a large multi-national company based in California. So the biggest difference between my classmates in India and me is that I pay my taxes to America, while they all pay a third of their salaries to India. That is a substantial contribution monetarily and I cannot compete with that sitting in America. Some of my taxes end up in Iraq and some of theirs end up in the Swiss bank accounts of some corrupt politicians. My friends in India are also influencing India in many other ways, with their taste in music, food, art, books and movies. Being in India also implies that you support all the local businesses and employ servants at home. So financially it is a significant loss for India, if you disregard the dollars sent back home by NRIs.
If you are reading this blog sitting in India, you are probably doing this using a CPU designed by Intel, using an OS developed by Microsoft, using a browser developed by Mozilla. (and maybe using an RSS reader developed by Google). There were definitely a few Indians who worked on all of these components. The point I am trying to make is that technology these days is created by people from all over the world, and it benefits people all over the world, but in most cases by companies head-quartered in America, with a vast majority of their employees in America, but from all parts of the globe. Are nationality and patriotism outdated concepts in our flat integrated world?
My ex-roommate J used to say that there are positives to staying in India or America for any individual. In the Bay Area you can get home quickly but then you spend many hours doing laundry, cooking, cleaning. In India, you spend a lot of time on the commute, but then you have servants to take care of most of the house-work. These days most things in India are identical to America, at home, at workplaces, at the malls, the movie theaters and banks. So the only difference is the traffic on the roads and other services the government provides.
There are probably a lot of Indians in America who carry "I owe you"s for India, and that might be one of the reasons for the success for charitable organizations like Asha and Vibha. I have been thinking about some of these points while writing this article, and I think the issue is too complicated to come to any conclusion. After 6 years in America, it has started to feel like home, but I do feel out of place from time to time. I don't look or talk like the natives and I sense a slight resentment from time to time, because my people have inundated parts of the country. And despite my best attempts at watching Jeopardy for the last 6 years, I am always stumped by a lot of categories, most Americans would have no trouble with. I feel like a misfit in India too at times, but on the whole I am more comfortable with being a first class citizen in India. I would like my children to share my values, and I feel like India is the place to raise kids. I hope someday I manage to move back and make my own small contribution to India, instead of carrying an "I owe you" to my grave. If you guys have misgivings about working for an American firm, please form a start-up and give me a job! ;-)