Wednesday, December 20, 2006

The Power of Beauty



A well-known quiz question goes "What is the unit of a woman's beauty?", the answer to which is one milli-Helen. It compares the beauty of a woman X to that of Helen of Troy, for whom legend has it, a 1000 ships sailed. In my personal opinion, although it makes for a very fancy quantification of beauty, that even manages to tickle one's funny bone, in reality it is a completely useless measure. Even the prettiest women of our times, for instance Penelope Cruz (personal opinion) or Demi Moore (a friend's personal opinion), may rate 0 on the Helen scale. The prettiest woman in Indian legend might be Mumtaz-mahal for whom the Taj Mahal was erected, but for the lack of a major naval fleet, Shah-Jahan may not have been successful at accentuating her Helen score. If only he had read the Illiad.

Another legendary beauty of our times without a doubt was Princess Diana. While the measure of beauty I am about to suggest further in this post is harder to quantify as elegantly as a Helen, Princess Diana definitely calls for a new definition of the unit of beauty.

I saw a movie today called "The Queen" which although slightly longish, tries to present a balanced story of what happened after the death of Princess Diana. Here are my two cents. While I think most people are inherently nice there are always two sides to any story. Some versions of events stay within the close walls of a palace , while others are more openly expressed.

What do I think of Princess Diana? I think she sounds like a wonderful person based on her actions. She seems to have realized the power of her own beauty and harnessed it to further some very worthy causes. But there is a certain problem in dealing with such people of exceptional beauty.

One thing strikes me as a very interesting phenomenon on Orkut. If you try to analyze the sexiness, coolness, trust-worthiness ratings of people on Orkut, I have noticed that usually these values tend to have some correlation. It is extremely rare that very pretty people are rated badly on coolness and trust-worthiness. While it could be true that being pretty, might put a rosy spin on whole lives and hence cause people to be genuinely good... or for trust-worthiness and coolness to make people more attractive. I think an equally probable (or more likely) explanation is that people tend to assume the best about good-looking people. Very often they get the benefit of doubt in ambiguous situations, they bring out the sympathies in fellow human beings, move up the ladder faster, get richer spouses...

None of us know whether Princess Diana was completely without fault in her relationship with the Royal family, but the press and general public always assume so. The power of beauty also stands corruption if absolute. While actions speak louder than words, we all make mistakes. Mistakes after all are relative. One man's terrorist is another man's martyr as they say.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

The one character not developed in the film is Diana herself. While she remains the poster girl of superficial popular culture, it was a very different Diana the Royal family had to deal with personally.

Both Diana and her brother, Charles Spencer, suffered from Borderline Personality Disorder caused by their mother's abandoning them as young children.  A google search reveals that Diana is considered a case study in BPD by mental health professionals.

For Charles Spencer, BPD meant insatiable sexual promiscuity (his wife was divorcing him at the time of Diana's death).

For Diana, BPD meant intense insecurity and insatiable need for attention and affection which even the best husband could never fulfill. 

From a BPD perspective, it's clear that the Royal family did not cause her "problems". Rather, she brought her multiple issues into the marriage, and the Royal family was hapless to deal with them.

Her illness, untreated, sowed the seeds of her fast and unstable lifestyle, and sadly, her tragic fate.

Saket said...

Hmm interesting comment red. We'll never know the truth I guess.

Anonymous said...

I read somewhere that Diana could not have fulfilled her royal duty as completely as she did if she suffered from BPD. I'm sure there is a lot about Diana we don't know, however I believe, as most people do, that the root of her problems were frustrations over an unfaithful husband and the establishment that expected her to except Camilla. I couldn't.

Anonymous said...

Yes, most people believe (or want to believe) "that the root cause of her problems were frustrations over an unfaithful husband..." Charles bad; Diana a victim.

But this is simply not true. Diana was typical of persons with BPD: she developed it at a very young age and would have brought her illness into ANY adult circumstances.

From the book, "Sometimes I Act Crazy (Living with Borderline Personality Disorder)", by Jerold J. Kreisman, M.D --

"In many ways, Diana was a typical girl, she also had dreams of marrying her prince who will whisk her off to their castle, but somewhere along the way she veered into a different dimension. She crossed the boundary from "ordinary" into "borderline" when her mother left abruptly when she was six.

During this time, Diana became moody and insecure. She would cling on to her stuffed animals, which she called them "my family". She felt she was not good enough to keep her real family together and developed a fear that everyone she loved would eventually abandon her.

When she was fifteen, Diana entered a pattern of bulimia which stayed with her for the rest of her life. The fractures in Diana's personality became more prominent when she could be charming, charitable and remarkably empathic at times, and then exhibited an unpredictable rage when disappointments arised. Sometimes she appeared calm and stoic, but at other times she became irrationally emotional, alternating between inconsolable grief and ferocious anger.

At twenty, Diana married her prince -- Prince Charles of England. Yet Princess Diana did not live happily ever after. As her fairy-tale marriage disintegrated, so did her manufactured facade of equanimity. She became more overly impulsive and self-destructive. She threw herself into her charity work, perhaps hoping to derive for herself the kind of caretaking she was bestowing on others. The affliction of borderline personality disorder plagued Princess Diana until her untimely death in 1997."