Showing posts with label Freedom. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Freedom. Show all posts

Friday, December 07, 2007

Tryst with Destiny: Archives of TIME Magazine!



My father once told me that Winston Churchill was so opposed to the idea of Indian independence that during the debate on the Independence of India Act in the British Parliament, he predicted that the second-generation Indian politicians would be so corrupt that "They will tax even air!". I have to warn the readers of this blog that so far in spite of my best efforts, I haven't been able to confirm the veracity of this quote.

So hoping to ascertain the truth of the matter I tried to look through the archives of the BBC and TIME magazine. Although I didn't find any supporting evidence for the statement, I did learn many other interesting facts about India 60 years ago.

On racial discrimination in the India before independence, this article quotes:
The Bombay Royal Yacht Club, where no Indian could tread even as a member's guest, was about to close; the Government had refused to renew its lease. No more would the pink pukka sahibs and their leathery memsahibs stare glassily over the glassy bay. Gone from most of the smart hotels were the signs "Europeans only." In cool Simla, Indians now jostled along the Mall where 20 years ago no person in Indian dress would have been allowed.

To be barred from places in one's own motherland, is probably discrimination of the highest order. Thankfully these practices ended 60 years ago.

On the positives and negatives of British Rule over India:
The Balance Sheet. What after two centuries could be said of British rule in India? Credits & debits were both enormous. About as much land is irrigated in India today as in all the rest of the world. The Empire's biggest iron and steel plant is at Jamshedpur. The British had built up in India an incorruptible judicial system, a good police force, a vast (if substandard) network of roads, and the world's fourth largest railway system.

Yet Indians were still among the world's poorest people. Seventy-five percent hovered perpetually between gnawing hunger and outright starvation. Malaria, bubonic plague and a host of other diseases made an Indian's life expectancy at birth the world's lowest — 27 years.

The city of Rajahmundry would become Rajamahendravaram, which would be harder to spell, but since 87% of Indians could not write that would not matter so much.

Pandit Nehru in the Discovery of India talked about the wholesale looting of India that the British practiced and how the railway system and the roadways were all just a means for the British to steal the riches of my motherland. I think the magnitude of the British "despotism" can be judged best by these two numbers. The average life expectancy was 27 years and 87% of the population was illiterate. I am sure the per capita income would be similarly abysmal.

Much as we Indians revel in bashing our elected governments, and occasionally wax eloquent about quotes from British despots, the truth is India has done exceedingly well since she became free. Reminders like these from our past can serve to show how much better things are for at least a sizable fraction of the population. If we manage to share the benefits of freedom with more people in the next 60 years, it would all have been worthwhile. Whether India would have fared better under the rule of British despots for another 60 years is a question we shall never find a conclusive answer to.

Correction: Although I haven't been able to find a reliable source, this is the quotation from Churchill that my father refers to. There are references to this all over the Indian blogosphere.
"Power will go into the hands of rascals, rogues and freebooters. Not a bottle of water nor a loaf of bread shall escape taxation. Only air will be free and the blood of these hungry millions will be on the head of Mr Atlee. These are men of straw whom no trace will be found after a few years."