Showing posts with label IT industry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label IT industry. Show all posts

Thursday, December 13, 2007

It's raining engineers!


This is in response to a post on Ashutosh's blog about the sorry state of sciences in India.

Here is how I see it. With the flat world, instead of doing India's IT jobs only, Indians are now doing the whole world's IT jobs. Admittedly these young engineers are making way more money than their parents did, but in the process India loses experts in all other fields.

I agree with Professor Rao about the lack of complexity in most IT jobs and how IT jobs are mundane. I think most people wouldn't do these jobs for as long as they do, because they don't truly enjoy them. This also means that most companies have productivity issues, attrition issues but that is another topic on it's own.

I disagree with Vivek about science only being about long-term projects and work that may not lead to practical benefits.

For instance if the Indian Government invested heavily in photo-voltaic cell research, where India decides to become the leader in high-efficiency photovoltaics, maybe in 10 years we will have a solar-energy industry which doesn't perform back-office operations for the world, but rather becomes the front-office that sends all it's monotonous manufacturing to another country, and keeps a higher fraction of the profits. By keeping the salaries of educators as low as they do in India, we do manage to keep inflation low, but we also manage to churn out millions of uneducated college graduates.

In the longer term economics is a big equalizer and sooner than later, the costs of doing business in India are going to be higher than some other country. The people with an aptitude for science, but training and experience in engineering, may find it hard to adjust in such a scenario. IT engineers made a quick buck for a few years, but no one ever assured them job security. The industry is brutal in that respect. Profit is the keyword, loyalty and charity are rare lapses.