The Joe the Plumber Subterfuge
I have been an involved bystander on the US presidential campaign. It is hard to ignore it living in America... if you aren't being bombarded with negative commercials while watching TV already, the debates, the PBS documentaries and the various comedy programs poking fun at the candidates will definitely get you into the action. One problem makes me realize how ordinary people seem to fall for the subterfuge dished out by the Republicans.
I was trying to find out some information on income distributions in the United States. The census.gov does have some tables with that information, but they stop short of giving you a graph with distribution, showing you where you stack up against the rest of the country. (Conspiracy theory? I think so. Isn't that the most obvious way to present and parse income data?) There are other blogs that tell you how incomes are distributed and it doesn't look like a pretty picture. The authors of this site called www.lcurve.org says it is an L curve. There is a huge spike of super-rich Americans.
The top one percent are now estimated to own between forty and fifty percent of the nation's wealth, more than the combined wealth of the bottom 95%.
Concentration of wealth produces concentration of power that is fundamentally incompatible with democracy. Why does our government give tax cuts to those on the vertical spike that result in cuts in services for the rest of us? The horizontal spike has the votes, but the vertical spike has the influence! They own the media. Your TV set is their pipeline into your brain! They set the agenda and the terms of debate. Furthermore, by the time you enter the voting booth all the
“serious” candidates have been filtered and pre-selected by their ability to raise funds from those on the vertical spike. Those who can’t attract big money are marginalized.
That's an argument that is hard to fight. Clearly the less smart Americans clearly don't see their own benefit. Admittedly Barack Obama probably misguides voters in some areas as well, but the Joe the Plumber episode just shows the lack of intelligence on the part of vast stretches of the country and the levels to which Republican leaders are willing to fool their countrymen. That might be one of the reasons why you pay high-school teachers peanuts, and make Math uncool. No one will be smart enough to understand that they are being fleeced.
Barack Obama claims that people earning less than 250,000 dollars a year will see a decrease in taxes under him. But Joe the Plumber claims he earns 250,000 dollars a year, and so John Mccain claims that Barack Obama will increase your taxes. And so people making 50,000 dollars cheer for Joe the Plumber at McCain rallies. Wow that is a new low in misguiding people. How the average Americans fall for this is beyond me... Part of it might be to sugar-coat whatever you say with plaudits for "small-town values", calling yourself "Joe Sixpack and Hockey Mom", with conjuring connections between your opponent and Al Qaeda and spreading false rumors about his religion and political views. While you are at it call yourself a "maverick" a few dozen times.
Again Barack Obama doesn't say he will stop outsourcing of jobs to foreign countries. He says he will stop providing tax breaks to companies shipping jobs overseas. That doesn't mean that outsourcing will grind to a halt. But it does seem like he is trying to reduce taxes for the middle and lower classes and prevent bankruptcies from health problems.
During the last election I saw the same style of attack ads against John Kerry by George W. In fact that episode introduced a new verb into the English language, swift-boating. If the past is any predictor of future behavior, America shouldn't elect McCain. Someone who makes commercials like George W Bush, is likely to rule like him as well. Someone who makes commercials like Bush, may also be more likely to rule, unless the country smartened up in the last 4 years, and sees through this subterfuge.










