Thursday, May 18, 2006

This blog supports the Anti-Quota Movement


BBC News Article 1

BBC News Article 2

A little late but I am against the stupid politicians all the same. I don't even think there should be reservations at colleges like COEP. The percentages are a problem... 50% is too much. Add to that reservations for girls and you have a recipe for stupidity. Plaudits to the students at AIIMS!

14 comments:

Wavefunction said...

It's never too late :)
Also, maybe this movement will hopefully convince the reservation catergory guys that there is nothing personal against them, only against low standards and politicians. The problem always has been that when an 'upper caste' guy speaks out against reservation, those guys always accuse him of having a personal caste based discriminatory vendetta against him. It is very important that they realise that the fight is only and always against low standards, irrespctive of the source of those standards.

Saket said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Wavefunction said...

I think that the major issues don't arise at such times. Even I got along well with my classmates who were from the reserved category, and in fact (hardly suprising), many of them were genuine and intelligent.
It's only when the issues really come up that you may have confrontations. My parents did not have a problem in their day to day dealings with people in Ferguson. But when the issue of promotion, salaries, recommendations came up, they as well as everyone else saw how polarised our society can be.

And you make a good point about IIT. If they relent, they should relent about all institutions.

Saket said...

Rewriting my old comment:

@Ashutosh
Yes I know that defence. You're against reservations because you are biased and you are a casteist.

I don't think so. I got along with everyone at my class pretty well even though the percentage of reservations was what it was during my time too.(I graduated in 2002) (49.5%)

Trouble is that if the government relents saying we don't want to force OBC reservations at IIT because their quality will flounder, well then why is the quality of IITs more important than other institutes?

@Crooger
Hehhehe... Hilarious comment. Azim Premji is pretty funny.

Saket said...

Yeah I am glad I didnt have to go through that phase. My parents didn't tell me a whole lot of this but I had heard that even at BJ faculty positions were very hard to come by for open category people. Even the topper of a class couldn't get a seat while there were vacancies for reserved people that used to get filled with someone who didn't do quite as well.

The faculty quality problem isn't as serious in medicine because most doctors who enter teaching are pretty good. There aren't any industry jobs per se and for most it is either going into a slow practice where patients are hard to come by, go aboard for FRCS or USAMLE or teach at some college.

Anonymous said...

arjun singh down down,he can never become PM,

Anonymous said...

what is the most effective way we can contribute for this issue?
Should ppl encourage more inter-cast marriage?
Let me rephrase it- should ppl neglect the caste option while choosing a life-partner?
In a flatter world, will acts like this flatten the rigid caste based system and attack the root of the problem?

Saket said...

Good point anonymus. What I'd say is that as long as people are labeled "backward" officially by the government even inter-caste marriages are going to be a challenge. To begin with people should stop being identified by their castes. The only way to create a new future is to forget the past.

Anonymous said...

Yes, Government will continue to do what it does.
Blaming on the govt is fine, but it is only the part of the action we should take.
We have to take the challenge of of breaking the barriers. But it will be gradual. It's difficult for people to shun the centuries-old traditions so easily.

Saket said...

Yep I agree with you. :)

Anonymous said...

One of the problems with reservation is that it removes the incentive for people to do well -- why does anyone study for months on end to do well on JEE ? If I knew I could get it in with 50% as opposed to 98%, I surely wouldn't bother studying.

Reservation was needed 50 years ago to give the "forgotten" a jump start. The hope would be to remove this once everyone has reached a common minimum standard. But in many ways, segregation has just increased in society since then -- public schools have gotten worse, anyone who can afford it will send their kids to private schools. The money divide is larger, the education divide is larger. Surely that wasn't the goal. Without a top down overhaul ("reservation" in good private middle schools and high schools or bringing public education to a respectable level), it isn't going to change.

Saket said...

I know what you mean. Trouble is that any government that takes away reservations will lose the next few elections most likely or at least so they believe. Vote banks are the problem. I don't think Arjun Singh or anyone really cares about the merits of their case and what is right or wrong. They are concerned simply with what is right for them in the short term. Our job is to ensure that the Congress loses the next election to show them that we have the collective power to bring them down.

Saket said...

I have seen that effect myself actually. One of my friends in class 12 used to mock us while we were studying. Apparently he was from one of the lower castes and he actually said something to the effect "You guys need to study... I am sure I'll get into a nice college regardless."

Although there is an economic restriction on who can get reservations, these things never get implemented well. Officially I think if your parents' income is above a certain level you aren't eligible for these seats I think. Someone correct me here if I am wrong.

Anonymous said...

Apart from reservations the govt has to concentrate on the quality of education to such people which is at present is running into junk in the govt run institutions.
Also it can be proposed for educational reservation that is they need to study only 75 % of the actual tenure.Such doctors be given operational reservation that is they can perform 60% of the operation and walk out of the operation theatre.Allow a politician to be the first one for such operation as an example to be followed